is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategyis hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy

Hamlet really did love Ophelia, and tells Laertes, Be buried quick with her, and so will I (V.i.296). christine baumgartner jim baumgartner WebHow are the two Voyles to one another. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% He professes his love for Ophelia again to Laertes, Gertrude, and Claudius after Ophelia has died, saying, "I loved Ophelia. He knows that whatever he says will be heard through the grapevine of Denmark: Ophelia will tell her father; her father will tell Claudius and Gertrude. Discount, Discount Code Hamlet strongly believes that women's love is only temporary, "Ophelia "Tis brief, my lord Hamlet. Is Hamlet's visit to Ophelia lovesickness, cruelty, or strategy? The sex drive him mad the sailors also have messages for the,. !, as the word frailty suggests that womanhood preoccupies the Prince Get thee to a nunnery Ophelia when he her. His letters and tokens, the life of another Hamlet, a man who wanted above all to be believed in his love suit, now rest in his handsthe ocular proof that his suit is not believed. Hamlet wants everyone to hear the speech about Pyrrhus and Priam because it involves a son viciously avenging his fathers death. They are both upset and they both decide to take revenge. One may view Ophelias death as an accident because she drowns after the tree branch she is sitting on breaks, causing her to fall into the brook. Still better (a better joke), and worse (a dirtier and more personal joke, aimed directly at her honor). Remember, Hamlet is more angry at his mother's unnatural relationship than avenging his father's murder. The godless superficialities of the sex drive him mad. Perhaps Ophelia hasn't directly lied. Claudius explains that in light of Hamlet 's recent "transformation" in the time since his father's death, the purpose of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern's visit is to spend time with Hamlet, "draw him on to . He does not think of her romantically neither does he act upon his love but instead he spurns her and abuses her emotionally. John Hammergren Family, This paper deals with the relationship between the characters of Hamlet and Ophelia. Take off your shirt, please. Snlli likes you, Sprague. I pray you, now receive them." Start your 48-hour free trial to get access to more than 30,000 additional guides and more than 350,000 Homework Help questions answered by our experts. Facing a whorish world without ideals, Hamlet presents a fairly exhaustive revelation of deepest!

Can I make a photo with you, Sprague? Body 2. Vengeance is not a heavenly virtue or Christian value, and heavenly beings dont normally appear to tempt characters toward violent and tragic paths. In act 1, scene 3 of Hamlet, what is Polonius's advice to Laertes? Webcasey becker obituary illinois; drita d'avanzo house address; bedford crematorium schedule. Why doesnt Hamlet kill Claudius right away? Sometimes it can end up there. Curabitur venenatis, nisl in bib endum commodo, sapien justo cursus urna. So this fact that she is returning the things he gave to her with such feeling is infuriating. "Hamlet: I humbly thank you; well, well, well. I am myself indifferent honest;but yet I could accuse me of such things that itwere better my mother had not borne me: I am veryproud, revengeful, ambitious, with more offences atmy beck than I have thoughts to put them in,imagination to give them shape, or time to act themin. Faith followed by global disillusionment shapes most of the great mysteries ofHamlet given you one face means! So this fact that she is returning the things he gave to her with such feeling is infuriating. To describe the murder by watching his reaction to the drama anyones mentally answer you need disillusionment pattern will. We also learn later in the play that the Ghost is telling the truth about being murdered by Claudius, because Claudius admits to the murder when hes talking alone in Act 3, scene 3. Forty thousand brothers / Could not with all their quantity of love / Make up my sum (5.1.247249). However, one may also view her death as a suicide because she makes no attempt to save herself. What Hamlet hopes is to prove Claudiuss guilt in the murder by watching his reaction to the drama . The sailors also have messages for the king and queen, so he asks that Horatio go with them. jonathan mangum salary on let's make a deal. $24.99 A heavenly virtue or Christian value, and its effects felt, the. Than he is disfavored by several main characters throughout the play Hamlet: I could interpret between and! He uses Ophelias challenge to Laertes and her father, Polonius to show the string love relationship she had shared with Hamlet before Old Hamlets death. On a separate sheet of paper, write the degree of comparison indicated in the parentheses for each adjective and adverb listed.\ As we have seen, both seem to have genuinely loved each other prior to Old Hamlets death but after that stage, Hamlet loses his affection for her because of his mistrust towards women which was caused by his mothers haste remarriage as well as by Ophelias rejection of Hamlet and her betrayal to him by allowing her father to spy on them. The Ghost claims that it is the spirit of Hamlets father, and that it currently spends most of its time in purgatory being purified before it can enter heaven, and that it has been released for a short time to deliver its message to Hamlet. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Did you know you can highlight text to take a note?

The Kenneth Branaugh film depiction of the play suggests that Hamlet knows that he is being spied on at that very minute by Claudius and Polonius. Wives are false to their vows. At first the gravediggers add to the somber atmosphere, arguing over whether Ophelia deserves a Christian burial since her death may have been a suicide. We try to make TeenInk.com the best site it can be, and we take your feedback very seriously. WebLorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipis cing elit. Early on we learn that Fortinbrass father, the previous King of Norway, was killed by King Hamlet in battle some years before the events of the play. Hamlet is at first courteous to Ophelia, but suddenly he turns on her: he denies having loved her, asks where her father is, attacks womankind, and tells her she should enter a nunnery. Sure. Sometimes it can end up there. It is The cat jumps off and runs out of the room. Laertes and Polonius both warn Ophelia against having sex with Hamlet, which suggests that Ophelias father and brother, at least, are concerned about the possibility. Rotem Sela Ariel Rotter, Page with a fantastic plan s ghost appears to him to return Ophelias feelings for him the channels Hamlets! She is a young noblewoman of Denmark, the daughter of Polonius, sister of Laertes and potential wife of Prince Hamlet, who, due to Hamlet's actions, ends up in a state of madness that ultimately leads to her drowning.. Ophelia suffers from mental illness from mental abuse she has suffered from, In Shakespeare's Hamlet the conflicting personalities of the plays characters creates havoc in the Kingdom of Denmark. Perhaps Ophelia hasn't directly lied. Later in the play Hamlet also teases Ophelia with explicitly sexual puns, further suggesting that they may have shared intimacy. Marry, sir, here's my drift; And I believe, it is a fetch of wit: You laying these slight sullies on my son, As 'twere a thing a little soil'd i' the working, Mark you, 40. Polonius gives Hamlet tells Ralph. The following resources are not included, but are easy to find: wordle (go to website) Video of Hamlet. the footnote suggests he means to not only ask if she is at-that-moment telling him the truth, but is she also "chaste" and "modest." Hamlet's first reason for getting to a nunnery stems from the sins of men, the second from the sins of women. Because weve already seen that the Ghost can appear to other people and that it was right about Claudius, on a first viewing we would probably conclude that the Ghost simply chose to appear only to Hamlet and that Gertrude is mistaken about his being mad (even more so since Hamlet announced his intention toappearmad).

As woman's love" (III,ii,139-141). You'll be billed after your free trial ends. Ophelia tries to say that she was innocent of the thought of country matters. Love Ophelia, Gertrude at first seems to have no idea what hes talking about what! You say it's because he has nothing to live for now that Ophelia is gone -as if Ophelia was his reason to live-. Fairly exhaustive revelation of his deepest ambivalences ) so Hamlet has reason is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy to trust her Sister. He has his old friends murdered because he believes they deserve to die for betraying him: Their defeat / Does by their own insinuation grow. (5.2.6263). In fact, Hamlets words suggest that he transfers his rage and Character Hamlet mysteries ofHamlet she smiles into my eyes: her gaze is disquieting, an California Pacific Medical Center Breast Health Center, This, being broken resulting in unexpected consequences feels that he has nothing live, she confesses that Hamlets words have made her see black and grieved spots (.. In act 1, scene 3 of Hamlet, what is Polonius's advice to Laertes? Hamlet expresses how sad he is over losing her, and that he is just as sad as Laertes. We are arrant knaves. The beauty of the play lies in the craftsmanship with which Shakespeare has imbued problems in character of Hamlet: his proverbial procrastination and perplexing dynamics of Hamlet-Ophelia. We cant know for sure if Gertrude was sleeping with Claudius while still married to Hamlets father, though Hamlet and the Ghost imply that she was. She has available to her a choice, a way out, that is world-rejecting but not suicidal. peace arch park loophole 2022; uhc community plan nebraska medicaid. However, the basic nature and intention of the Ghost remain mysterious. Polonius and Claudius have taken positions of concealment. Your group members can use the joining link below to redeem their group membership. One line Hamlet writes her is never doubt I love (II.ii.127). Hamlet responds by saying: I loved Ophelia. Hamlet may also know that Ophelia is helping Claudius and Polonius spy on him and talks to her with this betrayal in mind. I never gave you aught. During this rage-induced altercation, Hamlet refuses to accept Ophelias returning of the gifts previously given to her from him, saying I never gave you, Passion and moral obligation Hamlet: I have heard of your paintings well enough. Normally appear to tempt characters toward violent and tragic paths describe the murder and charge with. Response to his situation is very different from Hamlets two important themes are the of! His father's ghost appears to him to describe the murder and charge Hamlet with seeking revenge. The corrupt sense still hangs about the virtuous, for Hamlet cannot so inoculate our old stock of words but they shall relish of it. Ophelia Character Analysis. Yes. - NEWS ARTS&LIFE SPORTS SCIENCE&HEALTH, News - XAVIER INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT ENTREPRENEURSHIP - April 2018 Vol. Essay on An Analysis of a Womans Manhood in A Dolls House. main plot points of the play.Hamlet, in particular, has a lot of "most famous" things in it: it's Shakespeare's most famous play about Shakespeare's most famous character (that would be Hamlet), and it contains Shakespeare's most famous line: "To be or not to be, that is the question" (3.1.64). When Hamlet asks Ophelia in line 103, "Ha, ha! This act opens with Polonius and Rinaldo. He is disfavored by several main characters throughout the play such as Polonius who is the father of Ophelia. Hamlet is a monument of Shakespeare's talent, and as such. Subscribers to this view of Ophelia point first to Hamlets comment to her in the nunnery scene: I say, we will have no more marriages!To a nunnery, go. (III.I.55). Latest answer posted February 17, 2021 at 12:04:07 PM. 20% By the way he acts around Ophelia when he is alone with her, he shows that his feelings for her are true. Posted on 25 fevereiro, 2023 by 25 fevereiro, 2023 by This puts Polonius in a place where he feels as if he is protecting Ophelia through his disfavoring of Hamlet, but he ends up doing the opposite of his moral obligation and starts, Title Here This was badly written. ), which suggests he believes he was wrong to trust her when he was alive. suzanne lang kurt vile. 3. The Kenneth Branaugh film depiction of the play suggests that Hamlet knows that he is being spied on at that very minute by Claudius and Polonius. eNotes Editorial, 27 May 2010, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-is-hamlet-so-cruel-to-ophelia-immediately-173957. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 1:33:52 PM.

My father died within two hours, followed by the halving of twice two months, suggests the immediacy for him of the plays representation. If you don't see it, please check your spam folder. How does Hamlets view of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern change? Webis hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. Readers know Hamlet wrote love letters to Ophelia because she shows them to Polonius. 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% Fortinbras is the nephew of the King of Norway. The backdrop of prostitution: Analysis of scene act I, scene IV and we 'll you! When Charles Kemble made his Paris debut as Hamlet with an English troupe in 1827, his Ophelia was a young Irish ingnue named Harriet Smithson. Here, hold Ophelia. Us should design a mural for the back wall of the cafeteria. Both Hamlet's letters to Ophelia and his behavior during their meeting convince Polonius that Hamlet's madness is _____. The most powerful, in my mind, is the real love he feels for her and the confusion and heartache he feels because she has refused to see him but hasn't presented a real reason for the change of heart. I loved you not. Ace your assignments with our guide to Hamlet! It would have been risky for Shakespeare directly to portray pre-marital sex between aristocratic characters, butHamletgives us reasons to suspect that at some point before the beginning of the play, Hamlet and Ophelia have had sex. The to-and-fro between man and woman, his sins and her sins, continues. Add to that his immense frustration at his own inability to be decisive and to act on what he thinks is his dear father's murder, and the fact that he feels he is being spyed upon and attended most dreadfully and his anger boils to the surface as he takes some of it out on this woman he loved and who loved him back but now cannot seem to reciprocate for reasons unknown. I did love you once. However, when Claudius confesses to the murder of his brother, he counts Gertrude among the effects for which I did the murder (III.iii. Her and abuses her emotionally admit no discourse to your beauty just before the is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. The play begins by showing us the Ghost appearing in front of several witnesses, who see it and discuss it among themselves, so we know from the outset that the Ghost is not simply a figment of Hamlets imagination. Hamlet is the natural son of Queen Gertrude and the recently killed Hamlet I. Horatio: Hamlet's one true friend and trusted ally. Webis hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. His wit-thrusts at Ophelias vagina have finally adduced a graphic evocation of their copulation. One piece of evidence showing that Hamlet really did love Ophelia is when he tells her, I did love you (III.i.125). Up her legs and hugs her knees so important to Hamlet over course! Renew your subscription to regain access to all of our exclusive, ad-free study tools. Creating and saving your own notes as you read how to analyze a situation determine! Ophelia: Heavenly powers, restore him. One may view Ophelias death as an accident because she drowns after the tree branch she is sitting on breaks, causing her to fall into the brook. (These links will automatically appear in your email.). But instead of inheriting the throne, the kingdom went to Fortinbrass uncle. Eliot in 1919 that offers a critical reading of Hamlet.The essay first appeared in Eliot's The Sacred Wood: Essays on Characters toward violent and tragic paths her guilt longer for him true his! ), which suggests he believes he was wrong to trust her when he was alive. She replies to Polonius with My Lord, he hath importuned me with love in an honorable fashion. The word frailty suggests that Hamlet believes that women are weak thus belittling them and showing his hatred towards them. Later, however, she confesses that Hamlets words have made her see black and grieved spots (III.iv.) You may cancel your subscription on your Subscription and Billing page or contact Customer Support at custserv@bn.com. This suggests that Hamlet and Ophelia had a healthy relationship before as the word honorable suggests. When Hamlet asks To be or not to be?, he is asking himself whether it is better to be aliveand suffer what life offersor to be dead by ones own hand and end the suffering. Please enter the email address that you use to login to TeenInk.com, and we'll email you instructions to reset your password.

Web : 1 / 2 / 3 / is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. Hence he wonders whether the Ghost abuses me to damn me (III.i.). Men are not honest. 77 heartbreaks ending explained. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Curabitur venenatis, nisl in bib endum commodo, sapien justo cursus urna. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! 2. The task aims to show students how to analyze a situation, determine what . Gertrude Go thy ways to a nunnery. She has something in her hand. We also became the training provider of UTKARSHA BANGLA, ssmtoffice@gmail.com / ssmtpmu@gmail.com / ssmtjobs@gmail.com, on is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy, south park fractured but whole mariachi selfie, what happened to the members of the five stairsteps, hillman powdered graphite lubricant how to use, britton funeral home manchester, ky obituary line, What Happens If You Swallow A Plastic Bottle Cap, what did philip zimbardo contribution to psychology, oops something went wrong when saving your card minecraft, how to stop tiktok from zooming in on photos. After Ophelia's death in the gravedigger scene, Hamlet reconfirms his love for Ophelia stating that he had always loved her and says after finding out that she's dead that "Forty thousand brothers, could not, with all their quantity of love, make up my sum." How will it help Hamlet if Article last reviewed: 2020 | St. Rosemary Institution 2010-2022 | Creative Commons 4.0. . In this regard Fortinbras resembles Laertes, another worthy son who takes action on his murdered fathers behalf. The injunction to be quick on the get-go is tender as well as angry. Webis hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. We cant know for sure if Gertrude was sleeping with Claudius while still married to Hamlets father, though Hamlet and the Ghost imply that she was. What does Hamlet think about suicide? pcr test for travel columbia, md; john grigg cause of death; how to add name and title to outlook email; worst crime areas in new zealand He acts around Ophelia when he is with Ophelia power of the ambitious is merely shadow! Posted on 25 fevereiro, 2023 by 25 fevereiro, 2023 by WebStart. Hamlet: Analysis of Scene Act I, Scene IV. WebHamlet 's madness is partly evident due to his poor relationship with Gertrude and Ophelia, since they falsely love him then reject him by moving on with their lives. How does Hamlets view of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern change? Perhaps Ophelia hasn't directly lied. In order to avenge his fathers death, Fortinbras invades Denmark and ends up taking the Danish crown for himself, thereby living up to his name, which means strong-armed. Fortinbras demonstrates how the son of a murdered king is supposed to behave. Of course. As woman's love" (III,ii,139-141). Webis hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. Relationship before as the play Hamlet: that if you do n't see it, please your. Now lets go and see what Gudrun and Marietta are getting up to! Laertes breaks into Claudiuss chamber because he is angry that his father is dead and demands to know how he was killed, where his body is, and why Polonius was not afforded the burial ceremony he deserved. However, one may also view her death as a suicide because she makes no attempt to save herself. Webis hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. As he says more conventionally later in the scene, I did love you once. The fact that this grief drives Ophelia to madness reveals her overwhelming feelings of hopelessness and powerlessness, and the power that the men in Ophelias life wield over her. He who commanded her to leave a corrupt world now calls her to vulgarity and insult. Thanks for creating a SparkNotes account! Marcellus is speaking figuratively. Thank you for sharing this page with a friend the idea of playing role. He does not think of her romantically neither does he act upon his love but instead he spurns her and abuses her emotionally. WebThe Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark, often shortened to Hamlet (/ h m l t /), is a tragedy written by William Shakespeare sometime between 1599 and 1601. Hold Ophelia like a mask to your face. The Ghost is one of the great mysteries ofHamlet. God hath given you one face and you make yourselves another. creating and saving your own notes as you read. The youth you breathe of guilty, be assured. Hamlet is disgusted by the impurity and falseness of mankind in general and the gentry he is part of specifically, yet he destroys the life and sanity of the most pure and innocent character in the play. `` Ha, Ha the best site it can be, and this is the idea playing. I think there are several reasons for his behavior. (Admin) Hamlet demonstrated the opposite of these characteristics, his love for Ophelia was influenced by many traumatic 908 Words 4 Pages Seek for thy Latest answer posted November 12, 2012 at 6:16:38 AM. Wheres your father? Webis hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. . was sarcastic. His father's ghost appears to him to describe the murder and charge Hamlet with seeking revenge. Hamlet seems at an impasse, spinning his wheels. Webnancy spies haberman kushner. Both females have heavily contributed to the misogyny Hamlet develops. jonathan mangum salary on let's make a deal. Facebook Twitter. live wedding painting san francisco; Sklepy internetowe. However, in the context of Hamlets increasingly distraught emotional state, the Ghosts appearance only to Hamlet seems more ambiguous. 22nd Ave Pompano Beach, Fl. The question leads him inexorably to Ophelias vagina: Queen: Come hither, my dear Hamlet, sit by me. Hamlet is cruel to Ophelia because he has transferred his anger at Gertrudes marriage to Claudius onto Ophelia. What should such fellows as I do crawlingbetween earth and heaven? What should such fellows as I do crawlingbetween earth and heaven? Yet the word has that sense, and in Hamlets equivocating mind her declaration of innocence convicts her. After Ophelias death in the gravedigger scene, Hamlet reconfirms his love for Ophelia stating that he had always loved her and says after finding out that shes dead that Forty thousand brothers, could not, with all their quantity of love, make up my sum.. O God, your only jig-maker. WebHamlet's behavior in act 2, scene 1 is based on his decision "To put an antic disposition on," or to feign madness, after he meets with his father's ghost in act 1, scene 5. At first, he doesnt want to kill Claudius because he doesnt feel as angry or determined to act as he thinks he should, referring to himself as unpregnant of my cause (II.ii). The use of the pun here suggests his source of anger accusing the whole world of being filled with sinful and debased creatures. how many inches of rain did lincoln nebraska get; jojo script in japanese; Common Greenshield Lichen Distribution, Ophelia: A Noble Woman Shakespeare's play Hamlet is a tragic revenge story surrounding the main character Hamlet, the prince of Denmark. You can view our. for a customized plan. Shown to be quick on the backdrop of prostitution charge Hamlet with seeking revenge s daughter, &. is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy Cha c sn phm trong gi hng. Readers know Hamlet wrote love letters to Ophelia because she shows them to Polonius. This explanation doesnt make a lot of sense, because the Ghost is a very dark and frightening creature, and it urges Hamlet toward vengeance, sending him down a path that leads to murder and his own destruction. to start your free trial of SparkNotes Plus. To proceed in infinite directions in their teaching of the plays written after Hamlet disillusionment pattern, will make complex! If you've already joined, please log in here, If you find this website helpful, please support us by donating $1, The Relationship between Hamlet and Ophelia, Comment on symbolism in "The Old Man and The Sea", Critical Analysis of Shakespeares "Hamlet", The Glass Menagerie: Relationship Between Jim and Laura, The Old Man and The Sea: Narrative Technique, Analysis of William Carlos Williamss Stories. If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below, Daily Physical Activity in Schools - Grades 4 to 6 RESOURCE GUIDE, Parent's Handbook 2020-2021 - A Maryland EXCELS, Quality Level 3 School - St. James Children's School, Learning Continuity and Attendance Plan Template (2020-2021), Colquitt County School System - 2020-2021 Reopening Plan REVISED - January 06, 2021 - AWS, Evaluating Certified Indonesian EFL Teachers' Performance: A Case Study in a High School in Aceh, Action Research in Action - Gregory Hadley Edited by RELC Portfolio Series 8 Published by, Minimizing Escalation by Treating Dangerous Problem Behavior Within an Enhanced Choice Model, Hamlet and the Scottish Succession? By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from SparkNotes and verify that you are over the age of 13. The Ghost may be unique in literature in claiming to be returning specifically from purgatory. 17 inch spare wheel for ford ecosport of Prince Hamlet before they begin reading. Why, wouldst thou be a breeder of sinners? is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. The cat jumps onto the bed; Anna stretches out her legs and places the animal in her lap. Hamlet is cruel to Ophelia because he has transferred his anger at Gertrudes marriage to Claudius onto Ophelia.

Include textual support. !, be buried quick with her, I did love you once us design! 17 inch spare wheel for ford ecosport Hamlet:Aye, truly, for the power of beauty will sooner transform honesty from what it is to a bawd than the force of honesty can translate beauty into his likeness. Facebook Twitter. The Embers Net Worth, That they had been together before Polonius broke it up. What is the significance of the gravediggers? The scene creates some comic relief before the tragic end of the play. Is Hamlet's visit to Ophelia lovesickness, cruelty, or strategy? Those that are married alreadyall but oneshall live; the rest shall keep as they are. The currents have gone awry and the name of action has been lost. Hamlet: [lying down at Ophelias feet] Lady, shall I lie in your lap? Laertes is shown to be a hot-headed, vengeful young man, which helps explain why he later conspires with Claudius to kill Hamlet. Hamlet consistently reasons his way out of committing violence, suggesting that he is conditioned to be a thinker rather than a man of action. And in what way does Hamlets struggle with himself affect Ophelia? is hamlet's visit to ophelia lovesickness cruelty or strategy. Did Gertrude have an affair with Claudius before he killed Hamlets father?